I
re-read the classic from the late 1970s, 'Godel, Escher, Bach' by
Douglas Hofstadter. This book won the author his Pulitzer prize when he
was quite young. This book inspired a generation of Artificial
Intelligence researchers, which 30 years later has evolved to research
in 'cognition', i.e. how we perceive the world.
I
re-read this book every few years and alternate it with the other book
by Hofstadter titled, 'The Mind's I' - which is an anthology of essays
from scientists and mathematicians regarding how the sense of self
evolves in all of us. The themes range from mathematics to biology to
physics to AI.
I
am partial to the second book compared to the first. But both combined
are a very modern, and deep take on the evolving view of our sense of
self.
Every time I read these books, something new pops out for me to consider on its own merit.
In
this current reading of Godel, Escher and Bach, Hofstadter's notes on
Bach stood out. And in the main, his view of Bach's Crab Cannon. In
the 1750s, King Fredrick II gave the visiting Bach a small piece of a
tune and asked him to develop them into a multi-level fugue. Bach
succeeded in creating a marvelous and complex piece which was later
titled, "The Musical Offering'.
A
famous piece out of this musical offering is the crab cannon. It is
presented akin to a mobius strip. A mobius strip is an infinite loop.
An ant crawling on the mobius strip would cover both sides of the strip
in an infinite loop. It is the symbol for infinity that we all use in
mathematics.
Picture of Mobius Strip below and ants crawling on them:
The
following link is an excellent visual/musical illustration of the crab
cannon. It is a 3 - 4 minute piece that is worth listening to and shows
how Bach combines a tune that goes forward and backward into one fugue.
It is clever, it is melodious and in is revelatory.
I have a couple of additional notes should this topic that might be of interest:
Note I. Recursion:
The
main theme of Hofstatder's work is 'recursion.' It is a theme in
computer science, mathematics and logic. It represents objects that
repeat themselves in a self-similar way. An image of you looking into a
mirror with a mirror behind you will show an infinite set of images of
you looking at yourself. The most complete recursive mathematical set
was created by Benoit Mandelbrot. It looks like this:
Note
the recursion. Every little loop (even the tiniest) is a FULL repeat
of the big picture with no loss of fidelity. The point that Hofstadter
makes is that at sufficient levels of symbolic complexity, recursion
leads to self-awareness. Bottomline: our sense of 'I' is a recursion.
Note 2. Strange Loops
Hofstadter later wrote an entire book just on the strange loop. Which is the second note here, my earlier review of his book:
Hofstadter later wrote an entire book just on the strange loop. Which is the second note here, my earlier review of his book: